This guide will tell you everything you need to know to determine if a Nest vs ecobee thermostat is right for your home, and which model will best suit your budget, comfort needs, HVAC system, and preferences.
Thinking about buying a Nest or ecobee device? This comprehensive review will cover ecobee and Nest smart thermostats, including the models available, prices, warranty details, HVAC system compatibility, cool features and technologies, and more.
Smart thermostats are becoming increasingly popular as more and more homeowners embrace energy-saving technologies.
Beyond that, smart thermostats can also make your life more convenient by allowing you to see and adjust your furnace and air conditioner settings on the fly from anywhere in the world you have an internet connection.
Two of the most popular smart thermostat brands on the market are ecobee and Nest, and today’s review will help you decide which one is best for you.
ecobee vs. Nest Smart Thermostat Options and Prices
The products from ecobee and Nest are among the most popular smart thermostats in Canada, and each brand has a couple of models to choose from. Let’s review both ecobee and Nest smart thermostats for their key features and the price points of the models.
You can also check out our full Nest thermostat review and ecobee thermostat review for more details about each brand.
But first, let’s compare them side by side to help you decide which one is right for you.
The ecobee3 lite: $219.99
This is the least expensive smart thermostat from ecobee. It’s an intelligent thermostat that learns and adapts to your behaviour, and it’s also ENERGY STAR® certified, compatible with room sensors, and can be integrated with technologies like Apple HomeKit.
The ecobee Smart Thermostat with whole home sensors: $289.99
This is a bundle deal: you get a smart thermostat that’s similar to the ecobee3 lite in terms of capabilities and technologies, but you also get one SmartSensor and one SmartSensor for doors and windows. As such, this model comes with a higher price tag.
The ecobee SmartThermostat with voice control: $329.99
This is ecobee’s most expensive and sophisticated model, and you do get a SmartSensor included with the thermostat. This model comes with some additional perks, including Amazon Alexa and Spotify built in, voice control options, Bluetooth, and more.
The Nest Thermostat: $179.99
This is one of the most popular smart thermostats around, and part of that has to do with the affordable price. At the same time, this is a favourite among people who love programmable thermostats and still want to be able to control the heating and cooling settings in their home. That’s because this model doesn’t learn your habits and adjust settings accordingly.
The Nest Learning Thermostat: $329
This device does learn about your heating and cooling preferences and does make automatic adjustments to improve your comfort and save you money. This model has a lot of features and tech, including room sensor compatibility, so it costs quite a bit more than Nest’s other option.
Get Quotes
How soon are you looking to buy?*
Potential Energy Savings with Nest and ecobee Products
It’s difficult to say for sure how much a smart thermostat can save you on heating and cooling costs, but it’s generally understood that these devices can make your home more efficient and lower your energy bills.
The main reason behind this is scheduling: when either you or the thermostat creates a schedule that reduces energy use whenever possible (like during the day when you’re not home and at night when you’re asleep), cost-savings are sure to follow.
Both Nest and ecobee have done studies on their own devices and come up with some numbers about how much you can save using their smart thermostats:
ecobee says you can save up to 23 percent on your annual energy costs | with any of their smart thermostat models. |
Nest says you can save between 10 and 12 percent on your heating bills and 15 percent on cooling bills | with either of their smart thermostat models. |
Sensor Compatibility
Sensors are one of the newer and more exciting technologies to accompany smart thermostats, and these can include temperature sensors, occupancy sensors, light sensors, and door and window sensors.
ecobee
Every ecobee smart thermostat is compatible with the company’s SmartSensor, a sensor that can be placed in any room and moved easily to detect both temperature and occupancy, thereby ensuring ultimate comfort and energy savings.
Nest
Only the Nest Learning Thermostat is compatible with the Nest temperature sensor, a sensor that can be moved from room to room as you go about your daily routine. However, Nest smart sensors can’t detect occupancy like the ecobee ones, so there’s the potential that they aren’t as effective at ensuring energy savings and ideal comfort.
The Nest Thermostat isn’t compatible with the company’s room sensors, but it does come equipped with light, motion, humidity, and temperature sensors that are built right into the device.
Quick review of Nest and ecobee room sensor compatibility:
Brand | Model | Room Sensor Compatible? |
---|---|---|
Ecobee | ecobee3 lite | ✓ |
Ecobee | Smart Thermostat with whole home sensors | ✓ |
Ecobee | SmartThermostat with voice control | ✓ |
Nest | Nest Thermostat | X |
Nest | Nest Learning Thermostat | ✓ |
Learning Capabilities
One of the coolest things about some smart thermostats is they’re capable of learning your habits and making adjustments or setting schedules based on that data.
For example, let’s say you program your smart thermostat to make the house warmer in the summer between the hours of 9 a.m. and 6 p.m., Monday through Friday. But let’s say the smart thermostat notices that you typically come home around 5:30 and have to adjust the settings to make the house cooler earlier. Over time, the smart thermostat will learn about that habit and automatically turn on the A/C at 5:30 instead of 6.
ecobee
All three ecobee smart thermostats come with eco+, a proprietary technology that enables the devices to learn about your heating and cooling habits and adjust temperature settings accordingly. Beyond that, the technology also factors in fluctuating energy costs at different times of day to maximize savings.
Here’s how it works: when you first install an ecobee device, you use it like a regular programmable thermostat by setting temperature schedules for different times of day and different days of the week.
Over time, the device will learn these habits and incorporate that information into an optimized schedule that’s customized to your comfort settings, and that also saves you money on energy costs and reduces humidity.
Nest
The Nest Thermostat is a more basic device, so it relies on you to program schedules. In this way, it works more like a programmable thermostat with Wi-Fi, so it’s great for hands-on homeowners who want complete control over their temperature settings.
On the other hand, the Nest Learning Thermostat has similar learning capabilities to the ecobee devices. When you install the thermostat, it will collect data about your habits during the first week and then customize money-saving schedules that change based on temperature, humidity levels, and the seasons.
Quick review of Nest and ecobee learning capabilities:
Brand | Model | Learning Capable? |
---|---|---|
Ecobee | ecobee3 lite | ✓ |
Ecobee | Smart Thermostat with whole home sensors | ✓ |
Ecobee | SmartThermostat with voice control | ✓ |
Nest | Nest Thermostat | X |
Nest | Nest Learning Thermostat | ✓ |
Technological Features and Perks with ecobee and Nest Smart Thermostats
Any review of Nest and ecobee smart thermostats would be incomplete without a discussion about the technologies and features that make the different devices special.
Features and technologies can include things like geofencing, voice control, apps, energy reporting, and more, so let’s look at what the two brands have to offer:
Tech/Feature | Description | Nest Grade | Ecobee Grade |
---|---|---|---|
Geofencing | Using your mobile device to communicate with the thermostat about when you come and go from the house | Home/Away settings can use multiple devices for geofencing | Geofencing can be enabled on one Android phone |
Voice control | Ability to control the thermostat using voice commands | Voice control is available only when the device is paired with a smart speaker or other similar device with the capability | Only the SmartThermostat with voice control has built-in voice control using Alexa, but the other two can be integrated with things like Alexa for voice control features |
Energy reports | Detailed information about how and when you use energy and how you could adjust settings to save | The Learning Thermostat has an energy history and provides monthly Home Reports | The Home IQ system offers extensive data on energy use through the web portal for all ecobee devices |
HVAC alerts | Alerts about potential issues with your HVAC system and reminders about maintenance and service | Nest has extensive alerts in place for HVAC problems of all kinds | ecobee offers basic alerts about your HVAC system performance |
Apps | Special apps for your mobile device that can be used to control, adjust, and monitor your HVAC system and settings | Setup and control are done through the Nest or Google Home app | The ecobee app can be used to control any device |
Voice assistants | Compatibility with external voice assistants like Alexa, Cortana, HomeKit, IFTTT, and Google Assistant | Compatible with a few voice assistants | Compatible with most voice assistants |
ENERGY STAR | Certified by ENERGY STAR to save money and energy | The Learning Thermostat is certified but the Nest Thermostat isn't | All three ecobee devices are certified |
Integration | Can be integrated with other smart home devices from the same brand | Can be integrated with other Nest smart home devices like cameras and doorbells | Can be integrated with other ecobee smart home devices like cameras and sensors |
Installation | Can the thermostat be installed easily as a DIY job, or does it need professional installation? | Installation can be done DIY for both devices, or there is professional installation available as well | Installation can be done DIY for all devices, or there is professional installation available as well |
Get Quotes
How soon are you looking to buy?*
HVAC System Compatibility
Buying a smart thermostat isn’t always as easy as picking the one you want and hanging it on your wall—you also have to make sure the device is compatible with your current heating and cooling systems.
ecobee smart thermostats are all designed to work with single- and two-stage furnaces, boilers, and some heat pumps/air conditioners. Plus, the thermostats are also compatible with one additional accessory, such as a dehumidifier or HRV.
You can check the company’s website to see if your specific system is compatible with their products.
The Nest Thermostat is compatible with 85 percent of 24-volt heating and cooling systems. The Nest Learning Thermostat is compatible with 95 percent of 24-volt heating and cooling systems.
You can also reference the Nest website to determine if your current system is compatible with their products.
Warranty Review for ecobee vs. Nest Devices
Nest warranty details
- The Nest Thermostat comes with a one-year warranty
- The Nest Learning Thermostat comes with a two-year warranty
- Nest temperature sensors are covered by a one-year warranty
- All Nest thermostats get an additional year of warranty coverage when installed by a Nest Pro
ecobee warranty details
- The ecobee3 lite, the Smart Thermostat with whole home sensors, and the SmartThermostat with voice control are all backed by a three-year warranty
Review of ecobee and Nest Designs and Displays
ecobee smart thermostats all have the same sleek and modern rectangular design. They’re thin, lightweight, and have dark backgrounds with full-screen touchscreen displays that complement most décor styles.
The Nest Thermostat is round with a large, modern, mirrored display that clearly shows the temperature setting and current temperature. Settings can be changed using the touch bar on the side of the thermostat. This model comes in white, pink, grey, and charcoal.
The Nest Learning Thermostat has a look and feel that’s reminiscent of the old dial thermostats. It has a stainless steel ring around the outside that comes in several colours, and the display has a neat feature called Farsight, which automatically displays system information when you walk in the room.
FAQ
Which ecobee smart thermostat is the best?
The three smart thermostats from ecobee are all very similar in terms of design, functionality, and warranty. The main difference is the additional technologies and devices that come standard with the different models, and of course the price.
The ecobee3 lite is the basic thermostat; the Smart Thermostat with whole home sensors comes with two sensors; and the SmartThermostat with voice control comes with one sensor and built-in Amazon Alexa.
Which Nest smart thermostat is the best?
Both Nest smart thermostats have a lot to offer, but which one is best comes down to your own personal preferences. Whereas the Nest Thermostat is designed to be more like a programmable thermostat that gives you control over your heating and cooling settings, the Nest Learning Thermostat will learn your habits and create schedules for you.